Welcome!

Government Cloud Authors: Elizabeth White, Pat Romanski, Dana Gardner, Liz McMillan, Gopala Krishna Behara

Related Topics: Microservices Expo

Microservices Expo: News Item

Where Is the SOA in REST-Based SOA?

We must pare down the essentials of both REST and SOA to understand the true nature of the combined approach.

Over the years, updating our Licensed ZapThink Architect (LZA) course has given us ample time to explore advances in SOA and Cloud Computing. Now that we’re working on version 9 of the course, we’re taking a closer look at REST-based SOA. Of course, ZapThink has discussed REST for several years now, but recently we’ve seen some fascinating REST-based SOA case studies, both at startups as well as within the US Federal Government.

Nevertheless, while many architects believe that as an architectural style, REST is simpler and more straightforward that Web Services-based SOA, our research is turning up continued confusion over the principles of REST and how best to implement them. Everybody seems to get the basics—operate on resources at URIs with the four HTTP-centric operations GET, POST, PUT, and DELETE—but most people seem to miss the subtleties. Combine that confusion with the fact that you can do REST without SOA, the specifics of REST-based SOA are even more elusive, as we must pare down the essentials of both REST and SOA to understand the true nature of the combined approach. How, therefore, should we handle Service abstractions, contracts, and compositions – arguably, the essence of SOA – in a REST-based SOA world?

Where is the Service Abstraction?
At the center of the SOA approach is the notion of a Service abstraction. REST resources are abstractions as well, but resources are abstractions of capabilities or entities on the server, which is not quite the same thing as a Service abstraction. In SOA, the Service abstraction supports Business Services, which represent flexible, business-centric capabilities. A Business Service may abstract multiple Service interfaces, where routing and transformation operations on intermediaries present a loosely coupled façade.

Most RESTafarians, however, don’t think at this level. They are thinking of clients (e.g. browsers) accessing resources at URIs which return representations. A representation is an HTML page, an XML file, a video, etc. The business context is lost in a sea of URI formats and Internet media types.

What RESTafarians often overlook is that the intermediary pattern is actually one of the core architectural constraints of REST. URIs need not point directly to resources; it is perfectly OK for an intermediary to resolve the URI into a physical endpoint. After all, that’s what DNS servers do!

From the SOA perspective, we can rely upon the intermediary to execute routing rules and transformations as necessary to support the business abstraction. Furthermore, we can establish and enforce the policy (as a part of our SOA governance framework) that the only allowed way to access resources is via endpoints on an intermediary. From the REST perspective, think DNS server on steroids: instead of simply resolving URLs to IP addresses, resolve any formal URI structure to physical resource endpoints by following a rich set of transformation and routing metadata.

Where is the Contract?
At the technical level, a Service is a contracted interface or an abstraction of contracted interfaces. Web Services have contracts that comply with WSDL, but there’s no equivalent of WSDL for REST resources. True, resources have uniform interfaces that the four HTTP operations define, but simply knowing you can GET a resource or POST to a resource doesn’t tell you anything about what that resource is supposed to do. Accessing a resource does give you a representation of that resource, however. Representations can comply with standard Internet media types (formerly known as MIME types), but even the media type specification is insufficient to qualify as a contract.

Sun Microsystems tried to promote the Web Application Description Language (WADL) as a RESTafarian alternative to WSDL, but work on WADL has largely petered out now that Sun is part of Oracle. The point to WADL was more to stub out REST resources in Java than to provide an implementation-neutral contract language in any case.

Where, then, is the contract? Let’s look at a simple REST example: the simplest, of course, being the Web itself. Let’s say you are filling in a form on a Web page and then hit submit. Where is the contract?

The form method is POST, and the POST data are the information that you filled into the form. The resource is identified by the form action URL. So far so good. Have you found the contract yet?

In this example, the contract is the Web form itself. The form specifies and constrains the POST data you may input, and specifies the form action, which is a hyperlink to the next resource. You browsed to the page with the Web form by following an earlier link or loading a URL for a resource that returned that Web page as a representation of that resource.

Remember, a REST application is a set of resources that return representations that link to other resources – in other words, hypermedia. One resource returns one or more representations (Web pages, XML files, etc.) that contain links to other resources, and it is those hyperlinks (and their associated metadata) that specify the application behavior.

While a Web page with a form is the simplest and most common example of how to contract POST data, we can generalize that form however we like, depending on what type of client we want to support. For machine-to-machine interactions, for example (that is, when the client is not simply a browser), the first resource may return an XML representation that provides a contracted interface to the client for POSTing to the linked resource. How your resource builds that representation is up to you.

In Web Services-based SOA we store the contract metadata in a centralized registry/repository. In REST-based SOA each resource is responsible for returning contract metadata either for itself or for any resource it hyperlinks to. As a result, we may not able to obtain contracts for resources we’re not (yet) able to access, but on the other hand, we can code our resources to dynamically generate contracts if we wish. In REST-based SOA, therefore, contract changes can be automated, where in Web Services-based SOA, contract change is a complex, manual process that requires rigorous governance.

Where is the Composition?
The third core characteristic of SOA we look for is the ability to compose Services into applications. Such compositions might be orchestrations, when they have a pre-defined flow, or choreographies, when the order of steps in the composition is not determined ahead of time.

A REST application, of course, is an example of a composition of resources. From the SOA perspective, furthermore, a REST application is a workflow – that is, a composition with human steps. We can also consider such compositions to be choreographies, because the order of steps depends upon which links the user clicks. Users may click links in a different order every time they work their way through the application.

The question still remains: how do we create automated orchestrations in the REST world? The answer is simpler than it looks. In REST, everything can be a resource. Therefore, orchestrations can be resources as well. An orchestration resource might return a BPEL representation or a BPMN representation or perhaps a simplified representation of an orchestration that doesn’t have the baggage of either BPEL or BPMN. If anything, establishing a pre-defined orchestration is simpler than a hypermedia composition, because the orchestration logic is static, while with a hypermedia composition, the underlying resource logic may change the composition logic on the fly. Just because we don’t have to fix our application state transitions ahead of time doesn’t mean we’re not allowed to.

The ZapThink Take
Over the more than ten years ZapThink has been writing about SOA, we’ve fought the battle to explain what SOA really was, fighting the deluge of misinformation from profit-seeking vendors and ill-informed industry analysts. Fortunately, this time vendors aren’t trying to coopt REST to sell software the way they did SOA, to be sure, but the fact still remains that there is extensive confusion and misinformation about REST, just as there still is for SOA.

Mix the two together, therefore, and you’re just asking for trouble. But the effort is worth the trouble, for one simple fact: done right, REST-based SOA actually works. It paves a path to the agile architecture that we’ve been seeking since we first dipped our toe into the ocean of distributed computing. Of course, there’s a catch: the “done right” bit. The devil is in the details.

ZapThink will be providing far more detail on this topic over the next year, in our ZapFlash newsletters, in the next version of our LZA course, and in our Podcasts and at our events. Our new REST-based SOA module in the LZA course in particular breaks new ground and lays the groundwork for simpler, more successful approaches to SOA. Hope to see you at one of our events or classes soon!

More Stories By Jason Bloomberg

Jason Bloomberg is a leading IT industry analyst, Forbes contributor, keynote speaker, and globally recognized expert on multiple disruptive trends in enterprise technology and digital transformation. He is ranked #5 on Onalytica’s list of top Digital Transformation influencers for 2018 and #15 on Jax’s list of top DevOps influencers for 2017, the only person to appear on both lists.

As founder and president of Agile Digital Transformation analyst firm Intellyx, he advises, writes, and speaks on a diverse set of topics, including digital transformation, artificial intelligence, cloud computing, devops, big data/analytics, cybersecurity, blockchain/bitcoin/cryptocurrency, no-code/low-code platforms and tools, organizational transformation, internet of things, enterprise architecture, SD-WAN/SDX, mainframes, hybrid IT, and legacy transformation, among other topics.

Mr. Bloomberg’s articles in Forbes are often viewed by more than 100,000 readers. During his career, he has published over 1,200 articles (over 200 for Forbes alone), spoken at over 400 conferences and webinars, and he has been quoted in the press and blogosphere over 2,000 times.

Mr. Bloomberg is the author or coauthor of four books: The Agile Architecture Revolution (Wiley, 2013), Service Orient or Be Doomed! How Service Orientation Will Change Your Business (Wiley, 2006), XML and Web Services Unleashed (SAMS Publishing, 2002), and Web Page Scripting Techniques (Hayden Books, 1996). His next book, Agile Digital Transformation, is due within the next year.

At SOA-focused industry analyst firm ZapThink from 2001 to 2013, Mr. Bloomberg created and delivered the Licensed ZapThink Architect (LZA) Service-Oriented Architecture (SOA) course and associated credential, certifying over 1,700 professionals worldwide. He is one of the original Managing Partners of ZapThink LLC, which was acquired by Dovel Technologies in 2011.

Prior to ZapThink, Mr. Bloomberg built a diverse background in eBusiness technology management and industry analysis, including serving as a senior analyst in IDC’s eBusiness Advisory group, as well as holding eBusiness management positions at USWeb/CKS (later marchFIRST) and WaveBend Solutions (now Hitachi Consulting), and several software and web development positions.

IoT & Smart Cities Stories
The challenges of aggregating data from consumer-oriented devices, such as wearable technologies and smart thermostats, are fairly well-understood. However, there are a new set of challenges for IoT devices that generate megabytes or gigabytes of data per second. Certainly, the infrastructure will have to change, as those volumes of data will likely overwhelm the available bandwidth for aggregating the data into a central repository. Ochandarena discusses a whole new way to think about your next...
DXWorldEXPO LLC announced today that Big Data Federation to Exhibit at the 22nd International CloudEXPO, colocated with DevOpsSUMMIT and DXWorldEXPO, November 12-13, 2018 in New York City. Big Data Federation, Inc. develops and applies artificial intelligence to predict financial and economic events that matter. The company uncovers patterns and precise drivers of performance and outcomes with the aid of machine-learning algorithms, big data, and fundamental analysis. Their products are deployed...
Dynatrace is an application performance management software company with products for the information technology departments and digital business owners of medium and large businesses. Building the Future of Monitoring with Artificial Intelligence. Today we can collect lots and lots of performance data. We build beautiful dashboards and even have fancy query languages to access and transform the data. Still performance data is a secret language only a couple of people understand. The more busine...
All in Mobile is a place where we continually maximize their impact by fostering understanding, empathy, insights, creativity and joy. They believe that a truly useful and desirable mobile app doesn't need the brightest idea or the most advanced technology. A great product begins with understanding people. It's easy to think that customers will love your app, but can you justify it? They make sure your final app is something that users truly want and need. The only way to do this is by ...
CloudEXPO | DevOpsSUMMIT | DXWorldEXPO are the world's most influential, independent events where Cloud Computing was coined and where technology buyers and vendors meet to experience and discuss the big picture of Digital Transformation and all of the strategies, tactics, and tools they need to realize their goals. Sponsors of DXWorldEXPO | CloudEXPO benefit from unmatched branding, profile building and lead generation opportunities.
Digital Transformation and Disruption, Amazon Style - What You Can Learn. Chris Kocher is a co-founder of Grey Heron, a management and strategic marketing consulting firm. He has 25+ years in both strategic and hands-on operating experience helping executives and investors build revenues and shareholder value. He has consulted with over 130 companies on innovating with new business models, product strategies and monetization. Chris has held management positions at HP and Symantec in addition to ...
Cell networks have the advantage of long-range communications, reaching an estimated 90% of the world. But cell networks such as 2G, 3G and LTE consume lots of power and were designed for connecting people. They are not optimized for low- or battery-powered devices or for IoT applications with infrequently transmitted data. Cell IoT modules that support narrow-band IoT and 4G cell networks will enable cell connectivity, device management, and app enablement for low-power wide-area network IoT. B...
The hierarchical architecture that distributes "compute" within the network specially at the edge can enable new services by harnessing emerging technologies. But Edge-Compute comes at increased cost that needs to be managed and potentially augmented by creative architecture solutions as there will always a catching-up with the capacity demands. Processing power in smartphones has enhanced YoY and there is increasingly spare compute capacity that can be potentially pooled. Uber has successfully ...
SYS-CON Events announced today that CrowdReviews.com has been named “Media Sponsor” of SYS-CON's 22nd International Cloud Expo, which will take place on June 5–7, 2018, at the Javits Center in New York City, NY. CrowdReviews.com is a transparent online platform for determining which products and services are the best based on the opinion of the crowd. The crowd consists of Internet users that have experienced products and services first-hand and have an interest in letting other potential buye...
When talking IoT we often focus on the devices, the sensors, the hardware itself. The new smart appliances, the new smart or self-driving cars (which are amalgamations of many ‘things'). When we are looking at the world of IoT, we should take a step back, look at the big picture. What value are these devices providing. IoT is not about the devices, its about the data consumed and generated. The devices are tools, mechanisms, conduits. This paper discusses the considerations when dealing with the...